A Quick Note on the Breyer-Fried Discussion
We just got back from the very interesting discussion between Justice Stephen Breyer and Harvard Law School Professor Charles Fried, held at Georgetown Law School, and moderated by Professor Neal Katyal. We’ll post a full report — and photos — in the near future.
For now, though — we’re running out the door again — here’s our favorite part of the discussion.
Professor Katyal poses a hypothetical concerning whether, consistent with the First Amendment, a law could be passed forcing networks to replace entertainment shows like “Lost” with more civic-minded, educational fare, like vice-presidential debates. The example raises a tension between First Amendment freedom and Justice Breyer’s conception of the First Amendment’s purpose: promoting civic awareness and participation.
Professor Fried — who is a very dignified, elegant, and professorial older gentleman — starts to respond.
Professor Fried: “I watched Grey’s Anatomy for the first time last night, while flossing my teeth, in the other room. My wife doesn’t allow me to floss in the same room as her.”
[Laughter at this totally random domestic confession. The audience takes a moment to imagine Professor Fried in paisley pajamas, flossing his teeth, while his wife awaits his return in the bedroom.]
Professor Fried: “And I can assure you, the show is far more entertaining than any vice-presidential debate!”
Justice Breyer: “Gray’s Anatomy? I thought that was a medical text.”
Professor Fried: “You watch it, you’ll see that it ain’t!”
Unfortunately, the discussion quickly turns to campaign finance reform. We never learn whether Professor Fried favored “Dr. McDreamy” or “Dr. McVet” for Meredith Grey.




Comments
Lamest
Post
Ever.
Wow!
This is not Art. III groupie Lat. No one cares about this trivial crap.
Your readers want to know about two things:
1) firm gossip
2) reliable bonus information
You have thus far failed miserably on both counts. I can't think of single scoop broken on this site. I will give you a pass on bonus information but emploring your readers to give up the ghost and scouring greedy associates and XOXO are not going to get it done.
Reader tips and BB crap are only half the equation. The other half is genuine sources.
Professionals get results.
Now cut the b.s. beauty contests and get to work cause lord knows no one is going to read "supermogul" so someone has to cover those losses....
and you lose the race to report... BADLY... STILL NOTHING HERE!!!
I thought it was funny. I even forwarded it to a couple of friends in his con law class.
Not everybody who reads this page is a NY Biglaw associate only interested in dollar signs. Fried is, in my experience, quite a performer, and I enjoyed this.