Add RSS RSS

Do Robes Make the Judge?

ShawnDya L Simpson Judge ShawnDya Simpson.jpgOver the weekend, the New York Times had an interesting article about New York judges and their robes. It begins:

In Britain, judges are wedded to a tradition of elegant attire: scarlet and ermine robes, tippets over the shoulders, black girdles and, of course, the crimped, gray horsehair wig.

Minor correction: British judges have dispensed with wigs, except in criminal proceedings.

The article then discusses the robe-wearing styles of various judges. Judge ShawnDya Simpson, for example, “rarely fastens all the buttons and often accents [her robe] with a scarf or necklace,” or sometimes dispenses with a robe in favor of a lime-green suit.

Read more, after the jump.

Back at Our Very First Blog, Underneath Their Robes, we did a series of interviews with federal judges. We asked each interviewee about their fabulous judicial robes. Our favorite response came from Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw (9th Cir.):

8. Please tell us all there is to know about your fabulous judicial robes! For example:

(a) “Who are you wearing?”
(b) How many robes do you own?
(c) Do you have different robe styles for different occasions?
(d) Any tips on how to properly care for judicial robes?
(e) Do you ever wear your robe outside the courtroom? (Some possibilities: on Halloween; to costume parties; when traveling in the Middle East, accessorized with a black ski mask; or when you take your Jaguar in for servicing, to send a message of “Don’t overcharge me for those repairs—I may be a woman, but I’m a federal judge!”)

When I first arrived at the district court, Chief Judge Consuelo Marshall shared her robe-secret with me: all of her robes were designed by a retired Hollywood dress designer, Henri O’Bryant. He designed three for me before he passed away. The other two were gifts: one, a departing gift from O’Melveny & Myers, and the other, a gift from the Chancery Club. I keep one in San Francisco, two in my Pasadena chambers, and two at home for other travel. Some are dressier than others and are used (if I can find them) on special occasions. It has never even occurred to me to wear my robe outside the courtroom!

We love the idea of a Hollywood designer making judicial robes. We’ve actually suggested to the producers of Project Runway that they have a judicial robe design challenge in a future episode.

Speaking of Underneath Their Robes, we’ve been toying with the idea of letting a new writer take over UTR and generate new content, if we can find the right person for the job. If you might be interested, please click here for more details. Thanks.

Behind the Gavel, a Sense of Style [New York Times]
Do Robes Define Judges? ShawnDya Simpson Says No [WSJ Law Blog]

Comments

avatar
1 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 8:41 AM

Thirst for FIRRRRSSST
- Bill FIIRRRSST

avatar
2 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 8:52 AM

2nd 3rd 4th

avatar
3 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 9:01 AM

Defendants should be allowed to wear hot pants in the court room.

avatar
4 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 9:06 AM

"Judge Simpson said that being young and black already set her apart among judges."

But on television and in the movies, it seems that every judge is an African-American woman. Has anyone else noticed this?

avatar
5 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 9:12 AM

Am I missing something, or has ATL now defaulted to nothing but old stories with a link to the WSJ, which is always behind the times to begin with.

This is pathetic. You would be more interesting if you didn't post at all.

Hear that sound? It's the death rattle of ATL.

avatar
6 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 9:22 AM

9:12 - You are missing something. ATL's take on articles is very different from the WSJ's.

This is like complaining that The Daily Show does nothing but recycle stories from the New York Times and Washington Post.

avatar
7 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 9:24 AM

I LOVE the idea of a judicial robe challenge on Project Runway! Guest judge: Judge Judy.

avatar
8 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 9:35 AM

#4 - I have noticed that too. It is a conscious effort by the Hollywood elite to reshape public perception.

avatar
9 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 9:35 AM

Guys in my high school used to service judicial jaguars all the time, it was no big deal.

avatar
10 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 9:37 AM

I hope the robes worn by English judges don't smell as badly as the gowns worn by the barristers.

In Maryland, the judges of the Court of Appeals, the highest court, wear red robes. They look nice. Does anyone else wear something other than blacK/

avatar
11 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 10:09 AM

4 - They're playing to their viewer demographic. Men are at work so daytime TV is marketed to women with fantasies of power and influence. You can work out the minority angle for yourself, but I suspect it's a conscious example by networks (e.g., CourtTV) to "balance" the number of minority criminals that appear on COPS etc.

avatar
12 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 10:12 AM

10 - Canadian judges wear red too I think.

avatar
13 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 10:20 AM

Um Lat, have Ellie (sic) go run UTR...he isn't fit for this site! Shove him out on his gold brickin' hide!

avatar
14 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 10:23 AM

I remember some news clips covering the OJ Simpson's arraignment in LAs vegas in his latest troubles. The judges there wear dark blue velvet robes.

avatar
15 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 10:30 AM

Just a note - English judges may have discarded wigs for the most part, but the Scottish judges are a separate, distinct profession and still merrily don the horsehair wily-nily...

avatar
16 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 11:59 AM

If UTR returns in all its glory, I will rejoice!!

A3GG

avatar
17 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 1:15 PM

I'm not sure we need a separate UTR. How about a new writer under the A3G pseudonym just starts making posts on ATL?

avatar
18 Posted by guest | Permalink Tuesday, September 9, 2008 10:57 PM

The best robe is worn by Judge Wilson on the Eleventh Circuit. His robe has a leprechaun on the inside. Go Irish!!

Post Your Comment