Add RSS RSS

NYU Law Grade Reform: Another School Changes Horses Mid-Stream

New York University Law School NYU Law School Above the Law.JPGJust to be clear, we now live in a world where grading systems can be changed in the middle of the year just because students are not doing as well as the university would like.

It has been happening all across the country. Earlier this week, it happened at NYU:

As you may know, after lengthy deliberation the faculty recently approved a new grading curve, effective immediately. All fall 2008 classes (including early seven week classes) will be graded using this curve. The new curve includes a number of innovations, including the introduction of an A+ grade. We believe that the new curve will more accurately represent the achievements of our students to the outside world.

At some point, you’d think recent alumni would start to get very, very angry about all of these changes that make their transcripts look worse by comparison. People are losing their jobs and are having to send out their old law school transcripts to new prospective employers. But according to their alma mater, their transcripts do not accurately represent their achievements.

Also, I’ve still yet to hear a coherent educational argument for why these changes have to be made in the middle of the school year. One would expect major changes in the grading system to be carefully contemplated and cautiously implemented at the start of a class year. Instead, NYU Law is giving us another hasty reaction to the declining job market.

Maybe this is a necessary move. But if grades can be readjusted in the middle of the year just because of a faltering economy, why go through the charade of having grades in the first place? They should just change the system to: “Better Than A Columbia Law Student,” “Comparable to a Columbia Law Student,” and “Better Than A Hofstra Law Student.” That’s clearly all they’re going for anyway.

Read the full new system after the jump.

NYU LAW SCHOOL — MEMO — GRADE REFORM

To: All Students

From: Liam Murphy, Vice Dean

Re: New Grading Curve

As you may know, after lengthy deliberation the faculty recently approved a new grading curve, effective immediately. All fall 2008 classes (including early seven week classes) will be graded using this curve. The new curve includes a number of innovations, including the introduction of an A+ grade. We believe that the new curve will more accurately represent the achievements of our students to the outside world.

Here it is:

Mandatory First Year Curve

A+: 0-2% (target = 1%)
A: 7-13% (target = 10%)
A-: 16-24% (target = 20%)
Maximum for A tier = 31%
B+: 22-30% (target = 26%)
Maximum grades above B = 57%
B: remainder
B-: 4-8% (target = 6%)
C/D/F: 0-5%


Advisory Upper Level Curve, for classes with 28 or more students

A+: 0-2% (target = 1%) (mandatory cap*)
A: 7-13% (target = 10%)
A-:16-24% (target = 20%)
Maximum for A tier = 31%
B+: 22-30% (target = 26%)
Maximum grades above B = 57%
B: remainder
B-:4-11% (target 7-8%)
C/D/F: 0-5%

* The cap on the A+ grade is mandatory for all classes, even those with fewer than 28 students. However, at least one A+ can be awarded in every class in the law school.

Earlier: NYU Law Grade Reform: Another Law School Loses Its Fastball
Grade Reform at USC Gould School Of Law: Here’s a Free .1

Comments

Comments hidden for your protection. Show them anyway!

Post Your Comment