Bill Clinton, Celebrities, Clarence Thomas, Contests, Elizabeth Wurtzel, John Yoo, Law Schools, Politics, Reader Polls

Who Is Yale Law School’s Most Disgraceful Graduate?
A gallery of seven rogues and a poll.


Positions: founder and managing editor, Above the Law; founder, Underneath Their Robes.

The case for disgrace: It all started out innocently enough. I graduated from law school; clerked for a judge on the Ninth Circuit, and not one of the crazy liberal ones (Judge Diarmuid O’Scannlain); worked as a litigation associate, at Wachtell Lipton in New York; and then joined the U.S. Attorney’s office in my home state of New Jersey. But then I got bit by the blogging bug. The next thing I knew, I was pretending to be a judiciary- and fashion-obsessed woman, Article III Groupie (“A3G”) of Underneath Their Robes (“UTR”).

Writing a sassy and saucy blog about federal judges probably wasn’t the best thing for a federal prosecutor to be doing in his spare time. After I revealed my identity as A3G, in an interview with Jeffrey Toobin of the New Yorker, controversy ensued. I was on the Drudge Report. I almost got fired.

Thankfully I did not. My boss at the time, then-U.S. Attorney Chris Christie (now New Jersey’s governor), allowed me to remain in the office (with the blog shut down). I went back to being a prosecutor.

But I missed blogging. I eventually left my job as a prosecutor for a full-time writing job at the politics blog Wonkette. A few months later, in August 2006, I launched Above the Law. Four years later, as the managing editor of this notorious legal tabloid, I continue to drag a learned and once dignified profession through the mud.

The case against: Jeez — that’s a bit melodramatic, isn’t it? ATL can be snarky and edgy at times, but it has evolved into a useful and widely read source of news and entertainment about the legal profession.

(Also, I’m a mere blogger, not important enough for this honor. I put myself in here as a joke — and to preempt ATL commenters from answering the question presented in the title of this post by saying, “YOU ARE, LAT!!!”)

(hidden for your protection)

comments sponsored by

Show all comments