This is a case study as to why two roommates, who are both lawyers, need to find something better to do with their time...and why neither will "settle" the issue, but rather, throw another (yule) log on the fire...so to speak.
It should be noted that Roommate 1 is not religious (actually, quite hostile towards organized religion), Roommate 2 is religious...sort of.
Start from the bottom.
___________________________________
From: Roommate 1
To: "Roommate 2”
Sent: Tue, November 10, 2009 1:15:38 PM
Subject: Re: party
burn and defile?
________________________________________
From: "Roommate 2"
To: Roommate 1
Sent: Tue, November 10, 2009 12:50:06 PM
Subject: RE: party
Anyway do what you want
You know my opinion on the subject
Roommate 2, Esq.
________________________________________
From: Roommate 1 [mailto:Roommate 1]
Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2009 12:49 PM
To: Roommate 2
Subject: Re: party
good thing it's not a Christmas tree then.
oh, and I forget, according to the chosen people, wasn't islam the religion of hate...
________________________________________
From: " Roommate 2 "
To: Roommate 1
Sent: Tue, November 10, 2009 12:45:01 PM
Subject: RE: party
My religion teaches me to burn and defile Christmas trees
Roommate 2, Esq.
________________________________________
From: Roommate 1 [mailto:Roommate 1]
Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2009 12:44 PM
To: Roommate 2
Subject: Re: party
I would never tell you what to follow, that is my first tenent of my agnosticness...you can believe whatever you want, don't try to convert me. And further, I am completely open to you decorating for your chosen holiday....
________________________________________
From: " Roommate 2 "
To: Roommate 1
Sent: Tue, November 10, 2009 12:36:58 PM
Subject: RE: party
Not this fucking jew…please don’t teach me what I should follow
That is offensive
Roommate 2, Esq.
________________________________________
From: Roommate 1 [mailto:Roommate 1]
Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2009 12:36 PM
To: Roommate 2
Subject: Re: party
Christmas has become a mass marketed “holiday” event that is practiced by several faiths, non-religious, and even followed by some Jews.
The tree itself has no Christian symbolism, but actually has pagan origins:
Pre-Christian roots
Historically, there has been opposition to the custom of the Christmas tree because of its pagan origins. In 1851, parishioners in Cleveland , Ohio , USA condemned as a pagan practice the actions of the pastor, Henry Schwan, for decorating one of the earliest Christmas trees in an American Christian church. Robert Chambers in his 1832 Book of Days asserts that the festivities of Christmas "originally derived from the Roman Saturnalia, had afterwards been intermingled with the ceremonies observed by the British Druids at the period of winter-solstice, and at a subsequent period became incorporated with the grim mythology of the ancient Saxons. Two popular observances belonging to Christmas are more especially derived from the worship of our pagan ancestors—the hanging up of the mistletoe and the burning of the Yule log." Regarding the Christmas tree itself, Chambers assumes that it "seems to be a very ancient custom in Germany , and is probably a remnant of the splendid and fanciful pageants of the Middle Ages."
Other traditions relating to Christmas that may derive from Germanic pagan practices include the Christmas ham, Yule Goat, stuffing stockings, elements of Santa Claus and his nocturnal ride through the sky, and elements of Alpine folklore.[1]
There are also some accounts that place the earliest Christmas trees in Riga or in the Baltic (variously Estonia or Latvia), in both countries that the merchants of the Brotherhood of Black Heads guild have wrote papers about carrying trees to the city center, but with no mention what kind of tree did they talk about, in German bom doesn't necessarily mean a Christmas tree. In Tallinn the first document mentions such trees already in 1441. [2]
While the Christmas tree's pagan roots are generally accepted, there still are various legends of Christian origins for the tradition. Such legends often relate to Saint Boniface. Such as: Boniface, in the process of converting local pagans, cuts down Thor's Oak, a hallowed tree for the locals, and claims a fir tree growing in the Oak's roots to be a new symbol Jesus Christ for the converted locals. Francis Weisler argued that Christmas trees are “completely Christian in origin" and that "the Yule tree had no direct pagan connotation..." [3]
________________________________________
From: " Roommate 2 "
To: Roommate 1
Sent: Tue, November 10, 2009 11:42:37 AM
Subject: RE: party
Well I cant tell you not to, but don’t give me that crap that it is not a Christmas tree
________________________________________
From: Roommate 1 [mailto:Roommate 1]
Sent: Monday, November 09, 2009 5:20 PM
To: Roommate 2
Subject: Re: party
oh, and it's not a 'christmas' tree...I'm an agnostic...
so it's more of a..."I like how good pine trees smell and they look nice during the winter with lights on it" tree.
________________________________________
From: " Roommate 2 "
To: Roommate 1
Sent: Mon, November 9, 2009 5:16:04 PM
Subject: RE: party
But seriously my dad would freak out if I had a Christmas tree
Roommate 2, Esq.
________________________________________
From: Roommate 1 [mailto:Roommate 1]
Sent: Monday, November 09, 2009 5:14 PM
To: Roommate 2
Subject: Re: party
cool...oh, and I'm putting you on notice, I'm buying a tree...probably on the 30th or something like that. Would you like to decorate with Channukahamaba stuff?
________________________________________
From: " Roommate 2 "
To: Roommate 1
Sent: Mon, November 9, 2009 5:04:33 PM
Subject: RE: party
Should be ok …need to check
Roommate 2, Esq.
________________________________________
From: Roommate 1 [mailto:Roommate 1]
Sent: Monday, November 09, 2009 5:03 PM
To: Roommate 2
Subject: Re: party
No, not till Dec. 12th. I thought about doing one this weekend coming up but Bill and John are having a party on saturday, and I was going to be gone all day, so I pulled the plug. And the Dec. 12 thing, I came up with last night, so it's not set in stone. I just want to have a party in Dec. and my firm party is the 18th. You cool with a party on the 12th?
________________________________________
From: "Roommate 2"
To: Roommate 1
Sent: Mon, November 9, 2009 5:00:03 PM
Subject: party
Were you still planning on having a party sometime soon?