Trading Places: At NYU Law, A Clash Over Classes for Cash
Trading Places: it's no longer just a great eighties flick. It's what some NYU Law School students were trying to do, for cash -- until the administration got wind of it, and cracked down.
Several tipsters forwarded us this email:
To: All StudentsFrom: Liam Murphy, Vice Dean [FN1]
Re: Buying and Selling Places in Classes
Date: July 22, 2008
I have received reports of students offering to buy or sell places in classes that closed during the recent registration lottery. (The seller and the buyer agree on a time when the class will be dropped by the seller and requested by the buyer.)
I write to remind you that trading class spots for money or goods, or offering to do so, is a violation of law school rules. Places in law school classes are not the property of the enrolled student. Sanctions will be imposed on any seller of a class place and any student who buys a place from another student will be withdrawn from the class.
This deplorable practice will, fortunately, become a thing of the past when the School of Law's new registration system comes online for the 2009-2010 academic year. In the meantime, I urge you to behave responsibly and respect the integrity of our efforts to allot classes to students in a fair and proper manner.
C'mon, Dean Murphy -- don't you teach contracts? Isn't this a learning experience? Why are you cracking down on a bunch of enterprising law students who are applying law-and-economics principles to their daily lives?
The reactions of some students:
"In the frenzy over registration here at NYU, some students are offering cash for classes. Apparently, the school only likes it when it's getting paid for the privilege.""[T]hought it would be interesting post to see whether folks out there can make a cogent argument that places in law school classes are the property of the enrolled student. Not your typical post, but perhaps might be fun."
We agree -- it could be interesting. Have at it, in the comments. Thanks.
[FN1] Hubba-hubba! This Dean Murphy is pretty cute. And he's Australian, so he probably has one of those sexy Aussie accents. It's too bad he was not yet a dean at the time of ATL's Law School Dean Hotties Contest.

Last week we received an email from our law school alumni office with the subject heading "Yale Law School Job Opportunities for Alumni." It directed our attention to this
As we reported earlier this week, the latest U.S. News & World Report
A tipster sends us troubling news from the
Under the leadership of the beloved
Let's see, Cass Sunstein's "personal reasons" for leaving U. Chicago... hold on a sec. Isn't Professor Sunstein part of legal academia's most fabulous
* Linda Greenhouse to $300K! [
We bring you some news from the University of Virginia School of Law, which last year was voted
In an
In a front-page Wall Street Journal
It appears that the situation we
1. If you send one of your students to another law school, for a year-long stint as a visiting student, don't "apologize" for it -- even if that student has a severe peanut allergy, requiring the receiving school to "peanut-proof" itself for the year.
Finding a decent legal job is hard enough as it is. Having a career services office that's in complete disarray doesn't help. From a tipster:
It's time for a brief update on the
It's only Tuesday morning, and we've already done
Earlier today, Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad made a controversial appearance at Columbia University. The decision to invite Ahmadinejad was defended by President Lee Bollinger, who criticized Ahmadinejad and his views while introducing him, but condemned by Columbia Law School Dean David Schizer.
This email message, from Professor Erwin Chemerinsky to Duke law school faculty and students, went out ten minutes ago.




