The Ninth Circuit Curse

Here’s a little riddle: What do these three senators have in common?

Sen. Larry Craig (R-Idaho)

Sen. Ted Stevens (R-Alaska)

Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska)

First, they’re all Republican senators from underpopulated sparsely populated states.

Sponsored Content

Paying for Law School in 2025: A Straight-Talk Playbook

Juno has consistently secured the best private loan deals for students at the Top MBA programs since 2018—now they’re bringing that same offer to law students, at no cost. Students can check their personalized offers at juno.us/atl This article is for general information only and is not personal financial advice.

By Nicolas Echegaray, Wharton MBA ’21 & General Manager, Juno

Second, they’ve all run into ethical, legal, or political problems. You know all about Senator Craig — in fact, more than you ever wanted to. As for Senator Stevens, see here and here. As for Senator Murkowski, see here.

What’s the third thing they have in common? Find out, after the jump.

Here’s the third thing shared in common by this trio:

Sponsored Content

[E-BOOK] 5 AI Productivity Hacks To Save Time And Streamline Your Law Firm

Discover five practical ways to harness AI and eliminate busywork—so you can focus more on your clients and less on repetitive tasks.

By The MyCase Team

They were all big proponents of splitting the Ninth Circuit.

These senators are all victims of the fabled Ninth Circuit Curse: anyone who tries to mess with the Mighty Ninth eventually finds himself (or herself) in deep doo-doo.

There are legitimate arguments to be made in favor of splitting the circuit. See, e.g., here and here (testimony of our former boss).

But over the years, there has been lots of talk but no action on proposals to split the circuit. Is it because of the Ninth Circuit Curse?

Disorder in the court [Los Angeles Times]
Improving the Administration of Justice: A Proposal to Split the Ninth Circuit [Senate Judiciary Committee]