Courts

The Confirmation Speech That Doomed The SCOTUS Nominee It Was Meant To Save

Sure, the guy's mediocre, but don't mediocrities deserve a seat on the Court?

Answer: Judge G. Harrold Carswell. When Richard Nixon nominated Carswell, a Fifth Circuit judge, to fill Abe Fortas’s seat, opponents called his record thin and unearthed a 1948 speech in which he’d endorsed white supremacy. Senator Roman Hruska, tasked with defending him, told a TV interviewer that even if Carswell were mediocre, “there are a lot of mediocre judges and people and lawyers” who deserved representation — adding that the Court couldn’t be made up entirely of Brandeises, Frankfurters, and Cardozos. Read more here.

« Previous 1 2