Sports and the Law: Super Mario's Marijuana Admission, Mixed with a Dab of NFL Hypocrisy
At last weekend’s NFL draft, University of Michigan wide receiver Mario Manningham, who was once projected as a late first-round draft pick, saw his stock drop all the way to the third round (95th overall). This happened after he sent a letter to the 32 NFL teams admitting to having smoked marijuana in college. Only the Super Bowl champion New York Giants (incidentally owned by Fordham Law School graduate John Mara) did not become scared away from drafting the former Wolverines wide receiver.
According to published reports, Manningham, when initially asked about his past drug use in interviews, denied ever using marijuana. However, upon hiring an agent (something that Manningham had to delay based on the NFLPA’s new “junior rule”), he wrote a follow-up letter to NFL teams admitting the truth, adding that “I don’t use marijuana anymore — and I have passed tests since.”
Candor about past drug use can be tricky for certain NFL candidates. In many years, evidence of trying marijuana has been as damaging to an NFL prospect’s draft stock as it was to Douglas Ginsburg’s 1987 bid for Supreme Court nomination. In the 1995 NFL draft, for example, University of Miami defensive lineman Warren Sapp, who most had projected as the draft’s first overall pick, fell all the way to no. 11 upon news that he tested positive for marijuana at that year’s combine. Indeed, Manningham’s situation is a bit different. “Super Mario” actually passed his drug tests at the 2008 combine. He did, however, test positive for marijuana twice while at the University of Michigan.
There are some real reasons why certain NFL teams choose not to sign players who admit to having tried marijuana. First, there is the malum prohibitum argument. Marijuana is illegal in the United States. Someone that breaks the law in any capacity shows disrespect for authority. One who disrespects authority is more likely to disobey a team’s internal rules. This spells bad news, especially for disciplinarian coaches.
Then, there are the medical arguments against an athlete using marijuana, both with respect to short-term and long-term health risks. Finally, some NFL teams fear that players who test positive for marijuana in college or shortly thereafter are more likely to get suspended for marijuana use in the pros. (See, e.g., Ricky Williams).
But might there also be less valid reasons for teams to avoid pot-smoking players? Read more, after the jump.
(60) Comments
* Does the Supreme Court's Stoneridge decision give the "getaway drivers" of securities fraud a free pass? [
A woman is seeking an arrest warrant against suspended Tennessee Titans cornerback Adam "Pacman" Jones [pictured], claiming he punched her at an Atlanta strip club. Fulton County Magistrate Court officials told The Associated Press on Tuesday that 
Check out this 
Actually, as it turns out, Judge Jeffrey Levenson DID say he was sorry -- immediately after making the ill-considered gay football / "wide receiver" crack that made him our 
One of the perks of being a judge is that everyone has to laugh at your jokes. Except when they're in poor taste and arguably offensive.
* Don't try doing #2 at the Larry Craig airport bathroom, unless you want tourists photographing your ankles in a "wide stance." [
A tipster sent us this 
Michael Vick, dressed in a sober charcoal suit and gold tie, just made a short public statement about his case. He took no questions. Here are some excerpts.
The plea hearing for the embattled star quarterback took place this morning. One of Michael Vick's lawyers, Billy Martin, spoke to reporters on the courthouse steps. He stated that "this matter is concluded until December 10th, when Judge Hudson will sentence Michael Vick according to the plea agreement." He also announced that Vick will make a statement of his own at 11:30 AM today.
* Nurse sues Pacman. [
From 
